Bitfolio
TechExplainer

Layer 2 rollups: who runs them, and who is accountable if something goes wrong?

A rollup inherits Ethereum's security for its data, but someone still orders the transactions, runs the bridge and writes the code. This page looks at rollups through that lens: control, responsibility and what regulators have said about systems that call themselves decentralised.

Aerial night view of an elevated expressway interchange with streams of traffic lights
Photo: “Bangkok Expressway” by Mark Fischer, CC BY-SA 2.0, via flickr.com · Edited: duotone, cropped.

The short answer

A rollup runs transactions off Ethereum and posts the data back, but an operator called a sequencer usually orders them. No rollup-specific rules appear in our sources; IOSCO says 'decentralised' systems usually have people in control, and the US Treasury says AML duties still apply.

Key takeaways

  1. A rollup executes transactions outside Ethereum's main chain and posts the data back to it, where consensus is reached.
  2. Optimistic rollups rely on a challenge period, typically seven days, before withdrawals; ZK rollups attach validity proofs instead.
  3. A centralised sequencer can influence the order of transactions, and ethereum.org calls many layer 2 projects young and experimental.
  4. IOSCO's 2023 DeFi report says such systems usually have responsible persons who control or strongly influence them.
  5. The US Treasury says DeFi services acting as financial institutions must meet anti-money-laundering duties whatever they call themselves.

What is a rollup, in the fewest possible words?

Ethereum's main chain is called layer 1. A rollup, one kind of layer 2, runs transactions away from that chain and then posts the data back to layer 1, where consensus is reached1. ethereum.org describes rollups as bundling hundreds of transactions into one main-chain transaction so the fee is shared2.

ethereum.org describes two designs. Optimistic rollups assume a batch is valid unless someone challenges it with a fraud proof, usually within seven days3. ZK rollups submit a validity proof with each batch, so exits do not wait for a challenge window4. Since the Dencun upgrade of 13 March 2024, rollups can post data as cheaper blobs under EIP-484456.

For the engineering in depth, from fraud proofs and validity proofs to blob data, go deeper on Protocol Insights. The rest of this page asks who is in control.

Who actually controls a rollup?

Even with its data on Ethereum, a rollup has human and corporate pieces that users depend on.

Points of control in a rollup

ComponentRoleWhy it matters to you
Sequencer or operatorOrders and batches transactions, then posts them to Ethereum3If centralised, it can influence transaction ordering3
Rollup contract on EthereumStores the state root for each batch3Its code decides how deposits and exits work
Bonded validators (optimistic)Post blocks against a bond that can be slashed for fraud3Security assumes at least one honest party watches3
Proof generation (ZK)Produces validity proofs, often on specialised hardware4Costly hardware can concentrate who does the work4

Figure · Where control sits

Where control sitsUsers and appssend transactionsL4Sequencerorders and batchesL3Rollup contracton EthereumL2Ethereum layer 1data and settlementL1
  1. L4Users and appssend transactions
  2. L3Sequencerorders and batches
  3. L2Rollup contracton Ethereum
  4. L1Ethereum layer 1data and settlement

What have regulators said about 'decentralised' systems?

The sources reviewed here contain no rollup-specific rules. The closest official guidance concerns decentralised finance in general, and two documents are directly relevant to how a rollup's operators may be viewed.

Two official positions

  1. 1

    IOSCO, December 2023

    The global body of securities regulators issued nine policy recommendations for DeFi. It rejects the idea that such systems run with no humans involved, finding that there are usually responsible persons who control or significantly influence them7.

  2. 2

    US Treasury, April 2023

    Its illicit-finance assessment says DeFi services that function as financial institutions under the Bank Secrecy Act must meet anti-money-laundering obligations, whether or not they describe themselves as decentralised8.

IOSCO also lists governance and cross-chain bridges among the places where vulnerabilities sit, calling reliance on oracles and bridges a continuing significant risk7. For the wider policy picture, see our explainers on SEC vs CFTC and sanctions and crypto.

Note

What this does and does not mean

Neither document names a particular rollup or classifies layer 2 networks as a category. They show how regulators approach any system that claims to need no one in charge: they look for whoever has control.

Why does the bridge matter so much?

Moving money onto or off a rollup relies on bridge contracts. The US Treasury's assessment records that a DPRK-linked group took almost 620 million dollars from a blockchain project tied to the game Axie Infinity in March 2022, then the largest virtual asset theft to date, and about 100 million dollars from a cross-chain bridge called Horizon8. IOSCO, for its part, calls reliance on bridges a continuing significant risk7.

Risk warning

Bridging adds risk on top of Ethereum's

Bugs in bridge or rollup contracts can cause losses, and an optimistic rollup's own exit route typically takes seven days3. Start small, and read our risk disclosure.

What should you check before using a rollup?

  1. Is it really a rollup? A sidechain runs independently, and a validium keeps data off Ethereum; neither posts data to layer 1 like a rollup1.
  2. Who runs the sequencer? One operator means one party that can affect transaction order3.
  3. How do exits work? Know whether you face a challenge-period wait3.
  4. Has anyone assessed its risks? ethereum.org calls many layer 2 projects young and somewhat experimental and points users to independent risk reviews2.

Related reading: zero-knowledge proofs and smart contracts.

What do users get wrong about rollups and responsibility?

Common beginner mistakes

  1. Assuming Ethereum's security covers everything

    Data posted to layer 1 is protected by Ethereum, but the sequencer and bridge are separate points of failure3.

  2. Believing nobody is in charge

    IOSCO finds that so-called decentralised systems usually have responsible persons with control or influence7.

  3. Treating 'decentralised' as a legal exemption

    The US Treasury says AML duties depend on what a service does, not what it calls itself8.

  4. Forgetting the seven-day exit

    Withdrawals from an optimistic rollup straight to Ethereum wait out the challenge period3.

Frequently asked questions

Is a layer 2 a separate blockchain?

Yes. ethereum.org describes it as a separate chain that extends Ethereum and inherits its security guarantees2.

Are there US laws written specifically for rollups?

None appear in the sources reviewed for this page. The closest official material addresses DeFi broadly, such as the Treasury's 2023 assessment8 and IOSCO's 2023 recommendations7.

How long does rollup data stay on Ethereum?

Calldata stays on-chain, while blob data is kept for about 18 days5; the rollup's state root remains in its Ethereum contract3.

Why might a ZK rollup be more centralised in practice?

Generating proofs is computationally heavy and can require specialised hardware, which ethereum.org notes can concentrate who does that work4.

The bottom line

Rollups make Ethereum cheaper by moving execution to networks with their own operators, contracts and bridges. Those pieces are where control, and therefore responsibility, sits; IOSCO and the US Treasury have both said that a 'decentralised' label does not remove the people in charge.

Sources

  1. Scaling — ethereum.org developer documentation Primary source
  2. Layer 2: learn — ethereum.org Primary source
  3. Optimistic rollups — ethereum.org developer documentation Primary source
  4. Zero-knowledge rollups — ethereum.org developer documentation Primary source
  5. EIP-4844: Shard Blob Transactions — Ethereum Improvement Proposals (eips.ethereum.org), 2022 Primary source
  6. The history of Ethereum (network upgrades) — ethereum.org Primary source
  7. Final Report with Policy Recommendations for Decentralized Finance (DeFi) — International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO), 2023 Primary source
  8. Illicit Finance Risk Assessment of Decentralized Finance — U.S. Department of the Treasury, 2023 Primary source

How we checked this page: every figure above links to the numbered source it came from. Spotted an error? Tell the desk — see our editorial policy.