Bitfolio
MarketsExplainer

How did spot bitcoin ETFs become legal in the US, and which rules apply to them?

A spot bitcoin ETF is a legal structure before it is an investment. This page follows the paper trail: the court case, the SEC order, the limits the SEC put on its own decision and the rules that came after.

Education only, not investment, tax or legal advice. Crypto-assets are high-risk — risk disclosure.

The carved pediment and columns of the New York Stock Exchange building with a large US flag
Photo: “New York Stock Exchange” by Peter Kaminski, CC BY 2.0, via flickr.com · Edited: duotone, cropped.

The short answer

They became possible on 10 January 2024, when the SEC approved exchange rule changes to list 11 bitcoin-holding trusts. The products are exchange-listed commodity trusts, not funds registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940, so some familiar fund protections do not apply.

Key takeaways

  1. Legally, spot bitcoin products are commodity trusts listed on exchanges; regulators call them exchange-traded products (ETPs).
  2. The SEC approved them by order on 10 January 2024 after a federal appeals court said its rejection of Grayscale's earlier proposal was not adequately explained.
  3. The SEC chair limited the decision to products holding bitcoin and said it signalled nothing about crypto asset securities.
  4. The Investment Company Act of 1940 does not govern these trusts, but sponsors must still publish registration statements and periodic reports.
  5. In 2025 the SEC allowed in-kind creations and approved generic listing standards, so qualifying products no longer need their own rule change.

Why did the SEC say yes in January 2024 after years of refusals?

The decision came as an order granting accelerated approval to rule changes filed by three exchanges1. Two strands of reasoning appear in the record.

The path to the 10 January 2024 order

  1. 1

    A court ruling

    The D.C. Circuit held that the SEC had not adequately explained why it rejected Grayscale's earlier proposal12.

  2. 2

    A surveillance argument

    The exchanges had surveillance-sharing arrangements with the CME, where bitcoin futures trade. The SEC found spot and CME futures prices closely correlated, so manipulation in spot markets would likely show up where the CME can watch1.

  3. 3

    An order, not a law

    The SEC approved the exchanges' rule changes, allowing 11 named trusts to list across NYSE Arca, Nasdaq and Cboe BZX1.

What did the SEC deliberately not decide?

Chair Gary Gensler's statement on the same day set boundaries. The approval covered ETPs holding one non-security commodity, bitcoin, and was not a sign that the SEC would approve listing standards for crypto asset securities2. He also called bitcoin primarily a speculative, volatile asset and urged caution2.

Reading the January 2024 decision correctly

The approval didThe approval did not
Let three exchanges list 11 bitcoin-holding trusts1Endorse bitcoin as an investment2
Rely on surveillance sharing with the CME1Make the spot crypto platforms behind bitcoin's price SEC-registered3
Require sponsors to give full and fair disclosure2Bring the trusts under the 1940 Act3

For how the SEC and CFTC split oversight of crypto, see our SEC vs CFTC explainer and the SEC profile.

Which protections do shareholders actually get?

You gain some things and give up others compared with holding coins. On the plus side, the sponsor must disclose material information in a public registration statement and periodic filings2, and the SEC notes that a fund spares you some direct risks of using crypto platforms and handling keys yourself3. Our page on crypto custody covers those risks.

  • No 1940 Act framework. The trust is outside the law most funds are registered under3.
  • Ongoing sponsor fee. It steadily reduces the value of your shares3.
  • Price gaps. Shares can trade above or below the value of the bitcoin held3; the SEC explains that arbitrage by large dealers usually narrows such gaps without closing them at every moment4.
  • Unregistered underlying venues. The spot platforms that set bitcoin prices are not registered with the SEC3.

Risk warning

A regulated listing keeps the asset's risk

The SEC calls bitcoin and ether highly speculative, with prices that can swing widely3. A fund can lose most of its value if bitcoin does. This is education, not a recommendation; see our risk disclosure.

How have the rules changed since 2024?

Each step below is described as the SEC worded it. Approval to list is not the same as trading: for the ether trusts, the SEC said shares could not trade until each registration statement became effective6.

Figure · SEC decisions on crypto ETPs

SEC decisions on crypto ETPsJan 2024BTC trustsMay 2024Ether trustsapprovedJul 2024Ether funds tradeJul 2025In-kind allowedSep 2025Generic
  1. Jan 2024BTC trusts
  2. May 2024Ether trusts approved
  3. Jul 2024Ether funds trade
  4. Jul 2025In-kind allowed
  5. Sep 2025Generic

The July 2025 orders let authorized participants create and redeem shares with crypto itself rather than cash only7. The September 2025 generic listing standards mean exchanges can list a qualifying commodity trust without a separate SEC rule change8. A commodity qualifies if it trades on a market in the Intermarket Surveillance Group, has underlain a futures contract on a US designated contract market for at least six months, or already makes up at least 40% of a listed ETF's net assets; leveraged and inverse products are excluded9.

Frequently asked questions

Is a spot bitcoin ETF a security even though bitcoin is not?

What trades on the exchange is the trust's shares, not the coins3. In the approval statement the SEC chair described bitcoin itself as a non-security commodity2.

Who can create new shares with the trust?

Only authorized participants, usually large financial firms, dealing in big blocks called creation units. Everyone else buys and sells existing shares on the exchange4.

Did the SEC approve ether products the same way?

Yes, by an order of 23 May 2024 approving rule changes at the same three exchanges for eight ether-based ETPs6. Trading in three of the ether funds began on NYSE Arca on 23 July 202410.

Why did the CME matter to the SEC?

The SEC relied on surveillance-sharing arrangements with the CME, where bitcoin futures trade, because spot and futures prices moved closely together1.

The bottom line

Spot bitcoin ETFs exist because the SEC approved exchange rule changes in January 2024, prompted by a court ruling and a surveillance argument, and it later widened the route with in-kind creations and generic listing standards. The trusts sit outside the 1940 Act and keep all of bitcoin's price risk.

Sources

  1. Order Granting Accelerated Approval of Proposed Rule Changes ... to List and Trade Bitcoin-Based Commodity-Based Trust Shares and Trust Units (Release No. 34-99306) — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, 2024 Primary source
  2. Statement on the Approval of Spot Bitcoin Exchange-Traded Products (Chair Gary Gensler) — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, 2024 Primary source
  3. Exchange-Traded Products (ETPs) Providing Exposure to Bitcoin and Ether: Investor Bulletin — Investor.gov, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, 2024 Primary source
  4. Investor Bulletin: Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Office of Investor Education and Advocacy, 2012 Primary source
  5. Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) — Investor.gov, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission Primary source
  6. Order Granting Accelerated Approval of Proposed Rule Changes ... to List and Trade Shares of Ether-Based Exchange-Traded Products (Release No. 34-100224) — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, 2024 Primary source
  7. SEC Permits In-Kind Creations and Redemptions for Crypto ETPs (Press Release 2025-101) — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, 2025 Primary source
  8. SEC Approves Generic Listing Standards for Commodity-Based Trust Shares (Press Release 2025-121) — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, 2025 Primary source
  9. Order Granting Accelerated Approval of Proposed Rule Changes to Adopt Generic Listing Standards for Commodity-Based Trust Shares (Release No. 34-103995) — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, 2025 Primary source
  10. Order Granting Accelerated Approval ... to Permit the Listing and Trading of Options on the Bitwise Ethereum ETF, the Grayscale Ethereum Trust, and the Grayscale Ethereum Mini Trust (Release No. 34-102799) — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, 2025 Primary source

How we checked this page: every figure above links to the numbered source it came from. Spotted an error? Tell the desk — see our editorial policy.